Quick Fort Myers FL MLS Search

Browse All Horse Creek Properties for Sale

$1,925,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 226030680 MLS
Discover a rare expression of Florida luxury: a beautifully appointed lakefront residence paired with an extraordinary 2,208 SF DETACHED, CLIMATE-CONTROLLED GARAGE designed for the collector who refuses to compromise. Architecture, entertaining, and automotive space unite on an ideal homesite. The detached garage is a destination in itself: fully air-conditioned and finished to residential standards with porcelain tile, New Age Pro-Series steel cabinetry, dedicated storage, and 200-amp service. A 9,000-LB LIFT accommodates serious mechanical work. Four insulated, hurricane-impact overhead doors include two 12' x 12' bays, a 14' x 14' bay for taller vehicles, and a 10' x 8' opening into storage from the adjoining 576 SF covered carport. The attached garage adds another 1,215 air-conditioned SF with epoxy floors and matching cabinetry. Six remote-operated doors and two driveways offer ample room for vehicles and gatherings. A gracious front porch welcomes you inside the home, where volume ceilings, wood beams, and an open-concept layout showcase lake and fountain views. The living room flows into the kitchen and dining areas, while a den and formal dining room behind wood barn doors provide elegant flexibility. The kitchen features a large island, granite countertops, and stainless-steel appliances. Double doors open to the main suite, where two walk-in closets with built-in cabinetry complement an exquisite en suite bath. Three additional bedrooms and two baths sit privately on the opposite side of the home. One bedroom includes a Murphy bed with integrated desk and shelving, ideal for guests or a home office. Thoughtful upgrades include spray-foam insulation, impact-rated glass and doors, central vacuum, two tankless gas water heaters, a 500-lb in-ground propane tank, whole-house reverse osmosis, monitored security with five cameras, and Wi-Fi throughout the home, garage, and grounds. Wall-to-wall pocket sliders open to an expansive paver lanai designed for effortless entertaining. A covered seating and dining area with a stone-faced gas fireplace overlooks the saltwater pool and integrated spa, framed by lush landscaping and evening lighting. Beyond, a paver patio adds gathering space, while an illuminated walkway leads to a smokeless firepit at the water's edge. The detached garage can transform from an immaculate showcase into a climate-controlled retreat or entertaining venue capable of accommodating a party of 100. Horse Creek offers privacy and easy access, with quiet streets, generous lots, miles of nature trails, a 12-acre riverside park, and a kayak/canoe launch onto the Orange River. I-75, Downtown Fort Myers, shopping, dining, entertainment, SW Florida International Airport, and Gulf beaches are nearby. This is more than a home with an exceptional garage; it is a private Florida estate designed around the way you live, entertain, collect, and enjoy. Bring the collection. There's room for all of it.

12452 Limestone CT, Fort Myers

Courtesy of The Agency Naples.

$975,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 226027985 MLS
Welcome to Horse Creek - one of SWFL's only remaining old Florida-style gated communities nestled on the Orange River. Enjoy peace & serenity here without sacrificing everyday life conveniences. Sitting on a sprawling 1 acre lot with 8 fruit trees on the property -1 pomegranate, 2 avocado, 1 lime, 2 lemon, and 2 fig trees. This custom built, luxurious French-Colonial style concrete block home finished in Santa Barbara stucco offers a soft, elegant texture rarely found in modern Florida construction. With a brand new standing seam metal roof and a location in flood zone X (flood insurance not required) you can have peace of mind. The lot can accommodate a future outbuilding to store your RV, boat, or simply to have an incredible workshop or she-shed. The interior features 4 bedrooms(2 of the guest rooms are en-suite and 1 has a large walk in closet)+ den with closet, 3 full bathrooms, and many upgrades like a beautiful kitchen with granite counters, stainless steel appliances and a reverse osmosis faucet, tile throughout the main living areas, and plush carpet in the bedrooms, along with a private sitting area in the master bedroom. Enjoy the sounds of built in ceiling speakers located in the living room, Master Bedroom, and Lanai. The large 3 car garage with 220v outlet for electric vehicle charging gives plenty of space for your toys, and vehicles. The oversized outdoor lanai features hurricane shutters, an elegant custom pool and spa, as well as beautiful pavers. Horse Creek sits on 220 acres of natural splendor with 113 home sites and approximately 100 acres of oak hammocks and lakes. The 12-acre riverside community park is dog-friendly, and includes a fishing dock, covered picnic tables, a fire-pit, and a playground with swings and slides. You can easily store your kayak or canoe at the community river park, and explore the Orange River. Many residents own boats and RVs stored in their private outbuildings. For the more serious boater, the nearby Sweetwater Landing Marina on SR 31 offers dry and wet boat storage, as well as concierge launching facilities. Horse Creek is very convenient to I-75 at just 3 miles from the highway, and is surrounded by excellent, close-by area amenities like numerous award winning healthcare facilities, an endless array of restaurants both on the Caloosahatchee river and in downtown Fort Myers, as well as unbeatable quick access to Southwest Florida International Airport. FLOOD ZONE X - flood insurance not required!

4651 Castalia CT, Fort Myers

Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company.

$1,180,000
4 Beds 3.5 Baths 2026028843 MLS
HUGE PRICE DISCOUNT! This beautiful home is one of the very few in which everyone's first word upon entering is "WOW". Incredible planning and great design makes this beautiful home a truly magnificent place to live. This home is in the much sought after gated community of Horse Creek. This home is built for the harsh Florida summers as it is made of concrete block construction, wrapped in Hardy board (Concrete)Planking, on a stem wall; With a whole home Generac Automatic 24KW generator W/ 500gallon buried propane tank and a 500 gallon Whole home reverse osmosis water system, with two new A/C systems, you will be high, dry, eating popcorn and watching TV regardless of weather! The kitchen is a chef's dream. All appliances are GE "Cafe", including Refrigerator ,gas cooktop, wall mounted oven and combo microwave/convection oven...all surrounding a huge island with a 36 inch custom sink and breakfast bar next to a bay window overlooking the amazing pool area. The pool area was inspired by the Key West lodge in Disneyworld mimicking a lazy river boat dock. With a huge 'manufactured' tree and concrete columns with lanterns, surrounded by lush tropical plants, a sundeck area, framed in rock, truly amazing! A beautiful new outside kitchen and bar with Granite countertops, Summit freezer, ice maker, Fridge, and storage. The gas grille and "Turbo Burner are Alturi by Summerset. There are five powerful DC fans and an electric retractable awning to complete this outside oasis. The detached guest house has a large bed/living room, a full bath, kitchenette, storage, and its own A/C, comfortable and private for guests! The walkway from the main house to the guest house is fully screened for security. The 4 car garage is a great place for the mechanically adept with epoxied floors, central vacuum, automatic doors, and large storage area above the garage. As you look to the back of the fenced in back yard , note that the property continues through the oak trees for approx. 150ft, ending at a wooded preserve. No neighbors ever behind or in front of this home on 1.19 acres. Horse Creek has a large open area with picnic tables and grilles where you can hold very large gatherings if so desired. This home is encircled by Ring cameras, and all of the entry door locks are keypads. This amazing home really needs to be toured to realize just how special it all is. To top it all off, the HOA fees are amazingly low!

4140 Horse Creek BLVD, Fort Myers

Courtesy of Starlink Realty, Inc.

Selling Office: Starlink Realty, Inc.

$840,000
3 Beds 2.5 Baths 2026025825 MLS
Welcome to Horse Creek, one of Southwest Florida's most distinctive gated acreage communities, where timeless Old Florida architecture, wraparound porches, mature oak trees, and estate-sized homesites create a lifestyle that is becoming increasingly difficult to find. Situated on a private one-acre homesite, this beautifully maintained pool home offers over 2,300 square feet of living space with 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and a thoughtfully designed split-bedroom floor plan. At the heart of the home is a stunning octagonal dining room with soaring ceilings, an architectural centerpiece that creates an unforgettable setting for holiday gatherings, dinner parties, and special occasions. The welcoming wraparound porch sets the tone for relaxed country living, while inside, spacious living areas, abundant natural light, custom features, and seamless indoor-outdoor living provide comfort and functionality throughout. Step outside to your private backyard retreat featuring a saltwater pool surrounded by lush landscaping and plenty of room to enjoy Florida's year-round outdoor lifestyle. Recent improvements include a new well pump and a Level 2 EV charging outlet. The property also offers exceptional flexibility with a two-car garage connected by a covered breezeway-style carport that provides two additional covered parking spaces. One of the property's most valuable features is its approval for an additional outbuilding, allowing future owners the opportunity to add a workshop, RV or boat storage, hobby space, or additional garage space. Horse Creek is known for offering a rare combination of privacy and community, with approximately 100 acres of preserved natural areas, lakes, miles of walking trails, and a private riverside park along the Orange River featuring kayak and canoe launch facilities, covered kayak storage, picnic areas, playgrounds, and expansive green space. Just minutes from shopping, dining, I-75, and Southwest Florida International Airport, this property delivers the privacy of country living without sacrificing convenience. If you're searching for acreage, architectural character, room for your toys and hobbies, and a community unlike anything else in Fort Myers, 4621 Castalia Court deserves your attention.

4621 Castalia CT, Fort Myers

Courtesy of EXP Realty LLC.

Selling Office: FGC Non-MLS Office.

$1,250,000
4 Beds 4.5 Baths 2025013966 MLS
Welcome to 4030 Horse Creek Blvd, a show-stopping masterpiece in the highly sought-after community of Horse Creek! From the moment you arrive, the striking curb appeal, durable metal roof, and professionally landscaped exterior with nighttime lighting will captivate you. Set on 1.05 acres, this 4+den, 4.5 bath estate with a 3-car garage and just under 3,200 sq. ft. has been completely transformed with luxurious, high-end finishes and designer craftsmanship throughout. Built with solid poured concrete construction with impact windows, doors and pocket sliders, this home offers both modern elegance and peace of mind. Inside, soaring high ceilings enhance the open-concept layout featuring gorgeous LVP flooring throughout, a custom fireplace, a remodeled chef’s kitchen with a large island, built-in pebble ice maker, handmade custom cabinetry, Taj Mahal countertops in bathrooms, upgraded Delta faucets, and top-of-the-line commercial-grade stainless steel appliances, including a propane range and double oven. The first-floor primary suite is a dream retreat with custom his and hers closets, plantation shutters, and a completely remodeled spa-like bathroom boasting dual sinks, an oversized walk-in shower, a soaker tub, and generous countertop and storage space. Two additional guest bedrooms downstairs each feature their own private baths, along with a dedicated office/den off the living room. Upstairs, the spacious loft features double doors that lead out to a private deck overlooking the resort-style backyard oasis, shaded by majestic oak trees, plus there’s one more additional bedroom and bathroom. The screened-in lanai, featuring new metal framing, is perfect for entertaining, while the lush landscaping and outdoor lighting create a truly enchanting atmosphere. Recent upgrades include a new 5-ton A/C, new pool automation system and pump, new gutters, new exterior and interior paint, all new interior doors, new trim and baseboards, custom staircase and railing, new fans and lighting fixtures, upgraded electrical outlets, and exterior security cameras. The home also features smart-home technology with Alexa-compatible switches, color-changing interior and exterior lighting, and a propane generator hookup for added peace of mind. Located just minutes from I-75, commuting anywhere in SWFL is a breeze. Enjoy the private community park or kayak along the scenic Orange River. This is the perfect place to live in luxury yet remain peacefully on the outskirts of the hustle and bustle. Come see the transformation for yourself, you won't be disappointed. MAKE SURE TO WATCH THE COMPLETE VIDEO TOUR!

4030 Horse Creek BLVD, Fort Myers

Courtesy of Experience Real Estate Group L.

Selling Office: Premiere Plus Realty Company.

$750,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 225019283 MLS
This is it - a real show stopper- the one and only home available at this price point in Horse Creek- another just reentered the market at $2 million+. Daniel Wayne Homes brings its signature craftsmanship and character to this luxury estate, nestled among the winding roads and multi-million-dollar properties that embrace the serene Orange River. It’s the new take on Old Florida, and I bet you didn’t see this coming. Meticulously designed and flawlessly maintained, this custom-built home looks as if no one has ever lived in it. The floorplan? Absolutely perfect for entertaining. The kitchen is a chef’s dream—spacious and beautifully appointed with custom cabinetry, granite countertops, an island, GE appliances, an RO system, and under-cabinet lighting for that extra touch of ambiance. But the luxury doesn’t stop there. This home is packed with upgrades, including impact windows, a stunning pool and lanai overlooking the lake, special solar lights on the pool cage, solar blinds, and an electric Storm Smart lanai shutter. And let’s talk about the garage—because this isn’t just any garage. The oversized side-entry garage provides ample space for your vehicles, toys, and storage needs, complete with sleek, durable metal cabinets to keep everything organized in style. Horse Creek isn’t just a neighborhood; it’s a lifestyle. With walking trails, a kayak launch, a park, and a playground—all for a low monthly fee of just $175—it’s truly a rare find. Don’t miss your chance to call this gem home!

4700 Castalia CT, Fort Myers

Courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Fort Myers and the Islands. 239-826-6414

Selling Office: TRU Florida Realty.

$1,042,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 225000403 MLS
Waterfront 3br+den/ 3Bath old Florida style home in exclusive Horse Creek, a picturesque gated community that offers oversized homesites in a Florida nature setting. A former model home by Daniel Wayne, the Sabal III was build in 2013 with extensive upgrades: Outdoor kitchen and gas fireplace, stamped wood designed concrete front porch, huge view with super screen pool cage, cherry wood kitchen, soft close cabinets throughout, his and her custom build closets and much more. It's situated on over one acre overlooking a 3.5 plus acre lake in the back as well as a 2.5 acre lake in the front. The current owners were the first ones to move in 2018 and a separate garage building was added in 2017. Measuring 27'X30' with two garage doors to the front and back and a carport overhang it offers space for your RV or boat. The property is in outstanding manicured and maintained condition. New AC and water heater in 2022, new dishwasher & microwave in 2023, brand-new refrigerator in 2025. Electric build in fireplace in the living room on a custom stone wall, screens on the garage door and custom build in cabinets in the garage as well. The riverfront community park and nature preserve along the Orange River offers trails for hiking and running, a kayak/ canoe launch and seating areas to enjoy the scenic Florida nature. This community offers a unique lifestyle and is under great management that is constantly working to keep restrictions and fees low. No CDD fees. No flooding and no damages in hurricanes, only 5min to I-75. All furnishings are negotiable.

12091 Nokomis CT, Fort Myers

Courtesy of Venture Realty & Investments.

Selling Office: Century 21 Selling Paradise.

$975,000
4 Beds 4.5 Baths 224076536 MLS
Welcome to 4030 Horse Creek Blvd - Beautiful and Perfectly situated in the sought after gated Estate home community of Horse Creek. This Custom home was built and designed with Family, Entertaining and Safety in mind. It features 4 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms with Den/Office plus bonus Loft and an attached 3-car garage. The Soaring ceilings in the Great room and full wall of impact glass windows and doors allow Natural light to fill the home. The open Kitchen features quartz counters, island with additional prep sink, walk in pantry and breakfast nook. The first floor include two ensuite guest bedrooms and the Owners retreat with dual walk-in closets, double sinks, shower and soaking tub. Upstairs leads to the 4th bedroom w/full bath and large loft overlooking the living area and sun deck. The outdoor living space is Spectacular!! The full length screen lanai leads out to your resort style pool/spa and private oak covered backyard with preserve views for privacy. Home has earned several accolades and certifications for energy efficiency and superior construction. Boasting 10in Poured Concrete Walls, includes Impact windows, metal roof, Hardi plank siding, and Generator ready with buried Propane tank. Just a few step away is the private community park where you can enjoy: The playground, kayaking and fishing on the Orange River. This Truly is a wonderful home and community. Close to I75, RSW, Shopping, Dining and our World famous Beaches. PLEASE ENJOY THE VIRTUAL TOUR and the 3D WALKTHROUGH! No damage, loss of power or flooding from the hurricanes!

4030 Horse Creek BLVD, Fort Myers

Courtesy of RE/MAX Realty Group.

Selling Office: Experience Real Estate Group L.

$1,955,000
3 Beds 3.5 Baths 224071941 MLS
Enjoy the pinnacle of luxury country living in this exquisite custom-built home, situated in the prestigious Horse Creek community—a gated enclave offering expansive oversized homesites. This 2019 Daniel Wayne built estate home stands on 1.23 acres, with stunning preserve views and a coveted western rear exposure. Built to the highest standards, this residence boasts insulated concrete block construction, enhanced hurricane protection, impact windows, and a Kohler 25kw whole-house generator. Additional features include a 500-gallon buried propane tank, a Kinetico whole-house reverse osmosis system, and two Rinnai tankless water heaters, along with numerous upgrades throughout. Car enthusiasts will appreciate the oversized attached 3-car air-conditioned garage, complemented by a 1,500-square-foot detached air-conditioned garage that easily accommodates an RV, boat and additional vehicles. Upon entering through elegant steel French doors, you are greeted by an open floor plan highlighted by beautiful crown molding and tray ceilings. The gourmet kitchen is both stylish and functional, featuring an expansive island, quartz countertops, premium stainless-steel appliances, high-end European style cabinetry, a walk-in pantry, and a cozy breakfast nook. The living room’s expansive wall of sliders facilitates seamless indoor-outdoor living, leading to a luxurious outdoor space with a relaxing seating area, a gas burning fireplace, and a custom built outdoor grilling kitchen. This space overlooks the heated salt water pool and integrated heated spa, and provides superb views of the tranquil preserve beyond. The custom master suite includes a walk-through shower, a stunning free-standing tub, dual vanities, and two custom walk-in closets. Two guest suites are located on the opposite side of the home, while a large bonus room upstairs can serve as an office or guest bedroom. On the main level, an additional office space with elegant tall French doors opens to the living room. Discover the natural beauty of Horse Creek with miles of nature trails, a 12-acre riverside park, and a community kayak and canoe launch onto the Orange River. Enjoy this tranquil rural setting, all while benefiting from the convenience of being just minutes from I-75 and Downtown Fort Myers, with shopping, dining, entertainment, and SW Florida beaches only a short distance away. Horse Creek offers a truly extraordinary lifestyle.

4250 Nocatee LN, Fort Myers

Courtesy of The Agency Naples.

Selling Office: Keller Williams Elite Realty 2.

$1,500,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 223053489 MLS
Welcome to Horse Creek, a one-of-a-kind gated community with custom-built Old Florida Style homes nestled among gorgeous oak trees along the Orange River. This 2019 Daniel Wayne built pool home is situated on over 2 acres and offers lake views and desirable Southern rear exposure. Featuring expansive front and rear porches, a 3 car attached garage PLUS an additional detached 1584 sqft custom garage easily accommodating an RV and 6+ vehicles. You'll fall in love with the modern farmhouse finishes in this 4 bedroom, 3 full bath home, with an open concept floorplan and stunning views from the moment you enter. Soaring volume ceilings with custom wormy chestnut beams and tray details are sure to impress. The kitchen features a large island, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances. Kitchen RO and central vac. The main suite with french door entry provides lanai access and has 2 walk-in closets. Experience true indoor-outdoor living by transitioning thru the pocketing sliders to the expansive paver lanai. Enjoy the large under-roof seating/dining area, complete with an outdoor gas fireplace with stone facade, all overlooking the gas heated saltwater pool and integrated spa and gorgeous property. Explore nature on Horse Creek's 220 acres and enjoy a community launch onto the Orange River for canoes and kayaks, nature trails, and a 10 acre privately owned park. In a convenient location just minutes to I-75, shopping, dining and a short drive to Gulf Beaches!

12452 Limestone CT, Fort Myers

Courtesy of Caine Luxury Team.

Selling Office: Caine Luxury Team.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.

Horse Creek Real Estate & Homes